Grover / Cookie Monster (voice)

Mr. Johnson (voice)

Anything Muppet Boy (voice)

Anything Muppet Mother (voice)

Chef (voice)

Banana / Dog (voice)

Orange Juice (voice)

Cereal (voice)

Muffin (voice)

Milk (voice) / Cereal Girl (puppeteer)

Mr. Handford (archive footage)

Cereal Girl (voice)

Backup Monsters (voice)

Cereal Girl's Dad

Backup Monster (puppeteer)

Elmo (voice) / Backup Monster (puppeteer) / Performer - "The Pasta Song"

Performer - "Blueberry Mouth"

Telly Monster (voice)

Performer - "Telly's Lunch"

Little Miss Muffet (voice)